If you're hoping to romance Gale in Baldur's Gate 3, you'll need to fulfill his condition. Unfortunately, simply feeding him magical items may not be enough. While the comments suggest that it's not the rarity of the items that matter, but whether the game considers them magical, the specific items that can be given to Gale will have a tooltip that says "Gale can consume this" when hovered over.
So, what are some of the specific items that you can give to Gale to fulfill his condition? One such item is Komira's locket, which can be found in the game. Another item is the ring of color spray, which can be crafted using a ring of telekinesis and a vial of color spray. Finally, you can also give Gale the watcher's guide, which can be found in the game.
It's unclear if there is a time limit to feeding Gale these items, so it's best to give him an artifact when he asks. Keep in mind that Gale's condition is specific, so generic items will not work. However, by giving him the right items, you'll be one step closer to romance him in Baldur's Gate 3.
Dual Wield Mastery: Unleashing the Power of Two in Baldur's Gate 3
Solo Play in Baldur's Gate 3: Kill, Avoid, or Rely?
Druid Build Reddit: Exploring Multiclass Options in Baldur's Gate 3
Karlach's Good Ending in Baldur's Gate 3: Which Option is Best for Her and Your Game?